We use cookies to help us understand how you use our site, and make your experience better. To find out more read our privacy policy.

The Hollow Men

Film (Full Length) – 2008

David Russell
David Russell
16 Aug 2014 - 03.23am
Isn't amazing how nothing really changes. John Key was lying back then, and he still lies in exactly the same way. At the end of the documentary, as Brash is thrown out (lost the election because of the Exclusive Bretheren's actions) and John Key takes over, in reply to a question, he says " I never received any correspondence with the Bretheren, I was not aware of their campaign, I stand by everything I said, I have nothing to hide, if I did I would tell you up front, .. I am not stupid enough to know that these things don't come out" ..... but he forgets that earlier in the documentary he was filmed having a meeting with two Exclusive Bretheren members.... but of course,then as now, he remembers how important it is, that he has a very bad memory.
3 Jul 2013 - 11.58am

Because the National Party (at this time, though I have no doubt that all major parties continue to do so) gives a greater degree of influence to some portions of the constitutency than it does to others. This selection criteria is made without reference to the relative and legitimate 1-vote-per-person grundnorm of western democratic society. It is made on the basis of financial profitability.

How could this not be unethical? As contextual moral guidelines, political ethics direct politicians to accurately and fairly reflect and represent their ENTIRE constituency. Just because the problem is endemic in every political party does not make it "a dull narrative", it makes it a crucial problem which is generating a significant democratic deficit in this country.
16 Jan 2012 - 07.24pm
I have finished the first two clips, I am 40 minutes in, and I still don't see the purpose of this? How does this discredit Don Brash and the National Party? Is this a dull narrative about standard political practice in a rather inconsequential period? This documentary really does not provide any strange or unfamiliar dirt on a political party, a political party is supposed to represent a commonly held opinion and influence the constituency to vote in favour of that opinion, and therefore that party. That is what Don has done. That is what all politicians do, this is not unusual, this is not unethical. Labour does the same, ACT does the same, NZ First does the same, The Greens does the same, The Maori party does the same. There must be better dirt than this? I'll keep watching.
29 Nov 2011 - 11.08pm
John Key has flat out lied about his knowledge of the exclusive bretherens campaign. I don't mind their campaign because they paid for it but what strikes me is how Key can lie which shows me this man has no integrity. It has showed these last three years and it will continue the next three years.. I voted for National in 2008 but instead voted for Winston Peters in November. Now I am waiting for the master to cut John Key in small pieces. Winston has the facts to do the damage with.
Oliver Peryman
Oliver Peryman
29 Aug 2011 - 06.21pm
I'd like to pick out the documentary's final comments if I may. Here they are again:

"A week after he became leader, John Key flew to Canberra, a meeting had been arranged with the political strategists 'Crosby-Textor'. Key signed them up, and work began immediately on his two-year campaign to become Prime-Minister.''

The passage buttresses my own suspicion that the 'hollow men' have never actually gone away. It wouldn't suprise me if similar personnel and practices remain. Similarly, I wouldn't be suprised if the ongoing activity was captured by a kind of Hollow Men 'sequel'.

A wee story to end: In 2007 I attended a political science lecture where National's Simon Power was guest-speaking. I asked him if he knew of any continuing relationship between the National Party and the PR firm 'Crosby Textor'. He said no..
david scott
david scott
29 Aug 2011 - 02.04am
does xanadu know more about the leaks
1 Aug 2011 - 11.30pm
Someone should have done a documentary about the hollow lesbians from labour.
Ross Mackintosh
Ross Mackintosh
30 Jun 2011 - 09.43am
It appears that, in order to gain power, they (Brash, Key etc) were willing to compromise on everything. They planned to make the big changes in their second term. Looks like soon (next year) we'll get to find out just what they had in mind.
I wonder how many "swinging" voters will live to regret their decision to vote these people back in this November.
9 May 2011 - 04.02pm
First off, I'm by no means a National supporter, but this totally comes off as a overblown tirade against the party. As if it's just Brash who worries about his media image and personal branding, the only politician with a speech writer, or the only manipulative member of parliament. If you don't like his policies (I certainly don't!), that's one thing, but I don't think he's any more of a grease-ball than anyone else in parliament.
Mike McGavin
7 May 2011 - 06.16pm
I'm not convinced it's especially one-sided --- it just focuses on a particular subject, being the National Party leading into 2005. I know several people who (probably) voted for National and whom I think would perceive the documentary as showing a well run campaign rather than convince themselves there was unethical deception occurring.

Interestingly enough.
Morrissey Breen
Morrissey Breen
5 May 2011 - 10.24am
Brendan, you're a twit.
4 May 2011 - 10.15pm
I really take issue with taxpayer money being spent hosting this one sided attack on a New Zealand hero.

Shame on NZ on air for condoning the theft of Dr Brash's emails,
Alvina Barrett
Alvina Barrett
1 May 2011 - 09.07pm
‎"I think most people would say that Adolph Hitler was the personification of evil. I would say that Don Brash is a reincarnation of Hitler" and his party caucus are the campaigners; the military beasts, and crusaders that act against various ethnic groups (which, in my personal opinion, is the ultimate evil)
1 May 2011 - 05.56pm
Some questions (Q) and some observations (Obs):
Q1) Does Don Brash REALLY know the difference between right and wrong?
Q2) If Brash holds a position of influence post the 2011 election will he still recommend ditching our nuclear-free policies?
Q3) Is Simon Power stepping down in November because he finds the National-ACT behind-the-scenes plotting unpalatable? (Remember Power was one of the solitary Nats who declined offers of assistance from local Brethren in 2005.)
Obs.1) Brash's current media package is consistent with the Sinclair construction of 'an honest gentleman' ... hopefully all those journos who are still perpetuating this urban myth will be named so a gullible public can keep up with the cut and thrust of this evolving script?
30 Apr 2011 - 08.55pm
Observation: Anita Ferguson's face, when Rod Donald (politely) confronted Brash with the smoking gun: The Pamphlet :) Priceless! Personal Assistants know the truth lol
claire Bleakley
claire Bleakley
30 Apr 2011 - 07.18pm
"Gone by Christmas?"
Please keep your comments relevant to this title. Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments.

If you liked this, you might also like...

Collection image for Politics


Our representatives in Parliament have had some of their...

Thumbnail image for Someone Else's Country

Someone Else's Country

Another documentary by Alister Barry

Thumbnail image for A Civilised Society

A Civilised Society

Another documentary by Alister Barry

Thumbnail image for Mururoa 1973

Mururoa 1973

Another documentary by Alister Barry

Thumbnail image for Fallout


TV drama about NZ's nuclear free policy

Thumbnail image for Close Up - Big Dealers (featuring John Key)

Close Up - Big Dealers (featuring John Key)

John Key in his days as an exchange dealer

Thumbnail image for Gallery - Norman Kirk the First 250 Days

Gallery - Norman Kirk the First 250 Days

Another era of NZ politics?

Thumbnail image for Te Whānau o Aotearoa - Caretakers of the Land

Te Whānau o Aotearoa - Caretakers of the Land

Editor Abi King-Jones co-directed this

Thumbnail image for Leaving the Exclusive Brethren

Leaving the Exclusive Brethren

Doco about the Exclusive Brethren

Thumbnail image for This is New Zealand

This is New Zealand

Film made to promote NZ at Expo 70

Thumbnail image for Spin Doctors - Election Special

Spin Doctors - Election Special

A more satirical look at the NZ political process

Thumbnail image for Operation 8

Operation 8

Editor Abi King-Jones co-directed this

Thumbnail image for The Speaker

The Speaker

A short film where the Iwi/Kiwi billboard gets reinterpreted

Thumbnail image for 3 News - 'Corngate' interview with Helen Clark

3 News - 'Corngate' interview with Helen Clark

This fiery interview was based on Hager's Seeds of Distrust

Thumbnail image for He Toki Huna: New Zealand in Afghanistan

He Toki Huna: New Zealand in Afghanistan

Another 'truth to power' documentary featuring Nicki Hager

Thumbnail image for Hot Air

Hot Air

Another Alister Barry documentary

Thumbnail image for The 5th Eye

The 5th Eye

Also features Nicky Hager

Thumbnail image for I Spy (with My Five Eyes)

I Spy (with My Five Eyes)

Nicky Hager appears in this

Thumbnail image for Joe Bennett's Guide to the Corridors of Power

Joe Bennett's Guide to the Corridors of Power

Nicky Hager is interviewed in this

Thumbnail image for Havoc and Newsboy's Sell-Out Tour - I Spy

Havoc and Newsboy's Sell-Out Tour - I Spy

Havoc and Newsboy play I Spy

Thumbnail image for Newshub Nation - 1 March 2020

Newshub Nation - 1 March 2020

Features National MP Nikki Kaye

Thumbnail image for Interview with Prime Minister Keith Holyoake

Interview with Prime Minister Keith Holyoake

Interview with a National Party Prime Minister